Fukushima: The Facts
Fukushima: The Facts
On March 11, 2011, a major earthquake followed by a tsunami devastated part of Japan’s northeastern coast. The tsunami also severely damaged the Fukushima nuclear power plant, leading to a nuclear accident that resulted in significant radioactive releases.
Virtually impossible in Belgium
Such an accident could not occur in Belgium. Belgium is not known for being highly seismic, and tsunamis cannot occur there. From a technical standpoint, Belgian nuclear reactors have several advantages over the reactors at Fukushima. Belgian pressurized water reactors (PWRs) have three completely independent circuits, compared to two in the boiling water reactors (BWRs) at Fukushima. Furthermore, Belgian nuclear reactors are isolated from the outside by a double containment structure. Belgian reactor buildings are also equipped with passive hydrogen recombiners, which eliminate the risk of hydrogen explosions. This was not the case at Fukushima.
Immediately after the accident, a comprehensive plan was implemented both by the authorities to manage off-site contamination and by the operator, Tepco, to address the various consequences of the accident.
The nuclear industry is one of the most heavily regulated sectors in the world
To incorporate the initial lessons learned from the Fukushima accident, the European Commission implemented stress tests for all European nuclear power plants. The results of these European stress tests showed that Belgian facilities are among the most resilient in Europe and are robust enough to withstand extreme situations. Belgian nuclear power plants have multiple layers of safety and very strict procedures. The plants are also equipped with a double containment structure. The nuclear industry is one of the most heavily regulated sectors in the world.
Successful Stress Tests for Belgian Nuclear Power Plants
The European nuclear industry has learned from the disaster. Two weeks after the Fukushima accident, the European Commission decided to subject Europe’s 143 nuclear power plants to stress tests. These tests required an in-depth analysis of the safety measures each plant has in place to cope with large-scale natural disasters.
At the request of the Belgian Parliament, the scope of the stress tests was expanded to include other potential threats related to human activities and malicious acts. After analyzing all processes, ENSREG (European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group) submitted its conclusions. These confirm that Belgian nuclear power plants are among the most robust and that they maintain their essential safety functions in all scenarios considered.
A plan for additional actions was also drawn up to make improvements in various areas. This plan began in 2011 with very concrete measures and has continued to the present day with more significant projects. The wall built around the Tihange site to protect it against a flood that might occur once every 10,000 years is one example.
Fundamental Differences in Belgian Reactors
A series of natural disasters on the scale and with the suddenness seen in Fukushima is unthinkable in Belgium. Nevertheless, the European stress tests analyzed the safety margins available to power plants to cope with large-scale natural phenomena (earthquakes, floods, extreme weather conditions). For Belgium, the conclusions confirm the robustness of Belgian nuclear power plants.
Furthermore, it is important to highlight the difference in reactor type. In Belgium, the reactors are pressurized water reactors (PWRs), whereas in Fukushima, they are boiling water reactors (BWRs). From a technical standpoint, Belgian reactors offer undeniable advantages over the Fukushima reactors:
- Belgian PWRs (pressurized water reactors) have three completely independent circuits, compared to two for the BWRs (boiling water reactors) at Fukushima.
- From the outset, the seven Belgian reactors were designed with two containment vessels, separated by an annular space with reduced pressure.
- The Belgian reactor buildings are also equipped with passive hydrogen recombiners. The Fukushima reactors did not have such recombiners.
The two images below show a cross-section of the Fukushima BWR reactor and the reactor building.
The Fukushima Accident
The Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant has six reactors, all located on Japan’s east coast in an active seismic zone. On Friday, March 11, 2011, an earthquake measuring 9 on the Richter scale struck. It was one of the most powerful earthquakes ever to hit the country. The emergency shutdown was automatically triggered when the earthquake struck, bringing all power plants in the region to a halt. However, it took several more days before the plant reached a complete cold shutdown. In the meantime, the reactor, which was still generating residual heat, was cooled—in accordance with procedures—by the emergency cooling system.
The tsunami flooded a large part of the site and caused the loss of power supplies and freshwater cooling reserves.
Gradually, due to the lack of power and a cooling source, the water level in the reactor vessels of Units 1, 2, and 3 dropped, causing the fuel cores to melt. This resulted in significant releases of radioactive fission products in the form of aerosols and hydrogen inside the containment vessel. To reduce the pressure inside the containment vessel, plant operators vented hydrogen and aerosols into the atmosphere.
Rapid Evacuation
As early as March 11, Japanese authorities ordered the evacuation of residents within a 20-kilometer radius of the power plant.
The United Nations report (UNSCEAR, 2020) states that no significant health effects were observed in people exposed to radioactive radiation, nor are any long-term effects expected to be established. This can be explained as follows (according to the United Nations report):
- Thanks to the rapid evacuation of 160,000 people and the fact that the reactor explosions did not occur until four days later, very few people were exposed to high doses of radiation.
- The average radiation dose to which most population groups in the Fukushima region were exposed during the first year was less than 10 millisieverts, whether from radiation exposure or from ingesting contaminated food. Japanese authorities continue to systematically monitor the population that was exposed to radiation.
- The health status of workers present at the site after the disaster is being monitored closely.
The information is updated regularly and can be accessed directly on the website of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
MilliSievert
The sievert is the unit of measurement used to quantify the equivalent dose of ionising radiation to which a human being has been exposed over a defined period. The sievert is based on the biological effects of radiation. The Federal Agency for Nuclear Control (AFCN) estimates that the level of background radiation in Belgium is 2.5 millisieverts per year.
Let’s look at a few examples to illustrate what this represents:
- A chest X-ray: 0.02 mSv.
- A return flight from Brussels to New York: 0.10 mSv, and 2 to 4 mSv per year for crew members.
- Eating one banana a day for a year: 0.03 mSv.
- Living in the immediate vicinity of a nuclear power station: 0.002 mSv per year.
Fukushima: update from March 2021
Inside the Fukushima power station site
Every two months, the Japanese Government submits a report to the IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) summarising the actions taken and the progress made both inside and outside the Fukushima power station site. Following analysis, the IAEA issues its assessments and publishes them on its website.
Water management
Water management at the Fukushima site is based on three key areas: eliminating sources of contamination, isolating water from contamination and preventing leaks of contaminated water. Preventive measures and multi-barrier systems have been developed. The infrastructure put in place to reduce water ingress onto the site (from the ocean and groundwater) has been further strengthened in recent years through the construction of an underground ice wall.
Furthermore, the targets for reducing water ingress into the buildings have almost been met, even in the event of rain.
Inspections inside the containment vessels of the damaged reactors
The reactors are being maintained in a stable condition without any significant release of radioactive material into the environment. The most challenging task in the decommissioning process will be the recovery of fuel debris from within the reactors’ containment vessels.
In 2017, camera surveys were carried out inside the containment vessels of reactors 1, 2 and 3. The images obtained provide a better assessment of the true extent of the damage. Radioactivity measurements were also taken. Unit 4, which had also experienced a hydrogen explosion, was shut down at the time of the accident. The reactor was not damaged. Only the building housing the fuel assemblies was shaken. By the end of 2014, all the fuel assemblies had been removed.
The stages of decommissioning
The decommissioning of the Fukushima power station is taking place in two phases: the removal of the fuel assemblies from the spent fuel pools, followed by their dismantling. The pool at Unit 4 was completely emptied in 2014. Operations for Unit 3 began in 2017. The pools at Units 1 and 2 will follow. Decommissioning of the units can then begin.
Decontamination outside the site
Two zones had been designated by the Japanese authorities:
- A Special Decontamination Area
- An area comprising contaminated territories that had not been evacuated (Intensive Contamination Survey Area)
The Special Decontamination Area comprised the restricted zones as well as the planned evacuation zones located within a 20 km radius of the power station. All decontamination work in these areas was completed in 2017 and the evacuation orders were lifted. Within these municipalities, certain specific areas remain off-limits.
All soil and waste resulting from the decontamination operations are collected at interim storage facilities.
Water, food and discharges
Seawater quality, a continuous monitoring
In particular, the discharge of further-treated water into the ocean had no detectable effect on radiation levels in the marine environment.
Every month, TEPCO (the plant operator) submits a detailed report to the IAEA, which provides a record of seawater measurements taken in the immediate vicinity of the plant. Seawater readings and analyses show that radioactivity levels in the marine environment (seawater, sediments, biota) are very low and have not been affected by the decommissioning and contaminated water treatment activities carried out on site. In particular, the discharge of treated water into the ocean has had no discernible effect on radiation levels in the marine environment.
Find out more about the latest report
Monitoring of food products
Every month, analyses are carried out on samples of food products. Following the Fukushima accident, many countries had imposed restrictions on imports of Japanese food products, but most have now lifted or eased these restrictions.
Evacuation of local residents
In October 2017, Fukushima Prefecture reported that 54,579 people had been displaced as a result of the earthquake, the tsunami and the nuclear power station accident. In May 2012, this figure stood at 164,865 people. The United Nations report (UNSCEAR, 2020) states that there has been no significant effect on the health of people who have been exposed to radioactive radiation and that there will be no long-term effects.
Radioactivity in the air
The Japanese authorities have developed a system for monitoring radioactivity in the air. It is possible to view the daily radiation levels present in the atmosphere.
A sharp decline has been observed over the years, although levels have not yet returned to those seen before the accident. The difference amounts to around 1 milliSievert per year on top of natural radioactivity. It is worth noting that in Belgium, the amount of natural radiation absorbed varies from 2 milliSieverts (Flanders) to 10 milliSieverts (certain regions in the south-east of the country have high levels of radon in the soil).
Sources
United Nations, World Health Organisation (WHO), International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), European Commission, Federal Nuclear Regulatory Authority, World Nuclear Association, UNSCEAR (the United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation), TEPCO, IRSN, ENSREG.