Extending the operating life of nuclear power stations (“LTO”) is possible
Extending the operating life of nuclear power stations (“LTO”) is possible
Nuclear power stations can remain in operation beyond the 40 years originally intended. This decision was taken in Belgium, following the example of many other countries (Switzerland, the Netherlands, the United States) which have decided to continue operating their nuclear power stations. We explain below why a longer operating life for Belgian nuclear reactors (“LTO”, or Long-Term Operation) is possible.
Nuclear power stations do not have a technical end-of-life date
Power stations do not have a fixed operating life determined in advance. Originally designed to operate without incident for a minimum period, their operating life may be extended at any time (provided they meet safety criteria).
In Belgium, the law sets the decommissioning date for nuclear power stations. However, these stations may continue to operate provided that the necessary investments are made.
LTO: 60 years is the international standard; 80 years is the prevailing trend
The Netherlands decided to operate its Borssele nuclear power station, located on the Belgian border, for a period of 70 years (30 years of additional operation). Switzerland, too, decided to keep its nuclear power stations in operation for a further twenty years. The United States even intends to continue operating several nuclear power stations for up to 80 years. In other words, there is absolutely no technical or safety reason to justify closing our nuclear power stations after 40 or 50 years of operation.
Worldwide, it is common for nuclear power stations to have their operating lifetimes extended to 60 years or even longer. The European Commission forecasts that by 2035, more than half of all nuclear power stations in Europe (representing a capacity of around 60 GW) will be part of a long-term operating strategy.
Long-term operation and safety: an international perspective
The continuation of operations has international implications since, in addition to the oversight carried out by the Federal Agency for Nuclear Control (AFCN), further oversight is provided by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) at the request of the Belgian Government and the AFCN. As part of the ‘SALTO’ (Safety Aspects of Long-Term Operation) expert mission, the Doel and Tihange nuclear power stations were visited by several IAEA inspectors in 2016.
Long-term continued operation in Belgium: a tried-and-tested option
The decision to continue operating certain nuclear units is nothing new in Belgium. In the past, the Di Rupo 1 and Michel 1 governments decided, respectively, to continue operating Tihange 1 and Doel 1 and 2. Extending operations beyond 2025 will therefore not be a new development in our country. In the meantime, the operator has adopted the LTO concept and made the necessary investments to enable a potential ten-year extension of the operational life of the Tihange 1 and Doel 1 and 2 reactors, whilst complying with all safety standards.
In addition to the €600 million allocated to the continued operation of Tihange 1, the operator has invested some €700 million to support the extension of Doel 1 and Doel 2. The bulk of this sum is earmarked for upgrades and replacements (notably of the main turbines and transformers). Furthermore, new staff are being recruited and trained to ensure the safe operation of Doel 1, Doel 2 and Tihange 1.
Long-term operation: a political decision
Continuing to operate nuclear power stations beyond 40 years is a political choice, not a technical necessity. This is because the reactors at Doel and Tihange are no longer quite the same as they were 40 years ago: technology has evolved over time. Over the years, they have in fact been continuously updated and modernised. They also meet the strictest current standards. Continuing operation beyond 40 years is far from being an exception. Many other countries have taken this decision.
The operating life of the two newest reactors, Doel 4 and Tihange 3, has been secured
An agreement was finally signed at the end of 2023 to extend the operating life of Belgium’s two newest nuclear reactors, Doel 4 and Tihange 3. After more than a year and a half of negotiations between the Belgian government and the operator Engie Electrabel, the agreement was signed by both parties: Doel 4 and Tihange 3 will remain operational for a further 10 years, until 2035.
For the other reactors, an extension is becoming increasingly unrealistic. It will be up to the next government to decide whether the two newest reactors will be extended beyond 10 years, as some politicians have already suggested.
The withdrawal of the obsolete 2003 law on the nuclear phase-out, which prohibits the operation of new nuclear power stations after 2025, will also be on the agenda for the next government.